Why rural is hard to define

Part of the difficulty lies in picking a definition, says a Carolina Demography research analyst, but correctly doing so can improve the lives of rural residents.

Brown harvested cropfield with a tractor and trees in the distance.
(stock image)

What determines if an area is rural or not? Why is it relevant to distinguish between urban and rural at all? In this post, we talk about why defining rural areas is difficult, and how doing so correctly can improve the lives of those who live within them.

Part of the difficulty lies in picking a definition. The variety of criteria is representative of just how complex of a topic this can be.

How does the U.S Census Bureau define rural?

The U.S. Census Bureau defines rural as “an area that is not urban.”

So, what do they consider to be urban? An area that contains more than 50,000 people. Slightly less populated areas, those with greater than 2,500 but fewer than 50,000, are determined to be “urban clusters.” Any area of land that is not put into one of these categories would be considered rural.

This definition is mainly calculated by population density, though it is important to note that land cover and even airport location data are considered as well.

The Census Bureau updates the rural-urban classifications once a decade, following the decennial census. Thirty-four percent of North Carolina’s population was rural in 2010. The bureau has not yet released calculations based on the 2020 Census, but we expect this share to decrease due to patterns of growth observed over the decade.

What are some of the other methods the U.S. government and other organizations use to define rural?

Office of Management and Budget

The Office of Management and Budget takes a different approach to defining areas based on population density. According to the OMB, counties that are directly associated with an urbanized area containing 50,000 or more people are identified as metropolitan statistical areas. Counties that are associated with an urban area of greater than 10,000 but fewer than 50,000, are referred to as micropolitan statistical areas. In addition, counties in which 25% of the population commutes to an MSA are also considered to be metro areas.

As of March 2020, there are 384 metropolitan statistical areas and 543 micropolitan statistical areas in the United States. North Carolina is home to 15 of the former, and 26 of the latter.

U.S. Department of Agriculture

The U.S. Department of Agriculture takes on multiple methodologies within the same organization. Each one is program specific. For example, its Telecommunications Loan Program recognizes any area with fewer than 5,000 residents to be rural. At the same time, USDA has many other initiatives that categorize areas with up to 50,000 residents to be rural, as well.

N.C. Rural Center

We occasionally use the definition of rural provided by the N.C. Rural Center. It defines rural as a population density of 250 people per square mile or fewer. By this definition, 78 North Carolina counties out of 100 are classified as rural using 2020 Census data. (Two counties, Johnston and Onslow, transitioned from rural to urban under this definition between 2010 and 2020.)

Why are there so many different ways to distinguish rural areas from urban ones?

No one definition is “more correct,” so to speak. The existence of multiple methodologies allows for flexibility when applying the classifications.

The Census Bureau and OMB definitions are mainly used for statistical analysis. They provide clear-cut delineations of rural versus urban areas, even though they do so differently. The Health Research Services Administration notes that the OMB definition likely undercounts rural areas while the Census Bureau definition overcounts them.

On the other hand, the USDA’s flexibility allows for programs to target specific populations more effectively. For example, the Telecommunications Loan Program’s goal is to provide more areas with high-speed internet and reliable communication networks. They determine that 5,000 people is the threshold because studies have shown that those are the locations that need the most assistance with telecommunications infrastructure. Other USDA programs identify rural using issue-specific literature. Having an intentional target population increases the effectiveness of their policy or program.

Why is it important to distinguish between an area being rural and urban?

A large body of research has identified differences in economics, geography, demographics and culture between rural and urban areas. These community-defining characteristics have significant implications for legislative efforts at all levels of government.

We can see some of these differences in the following areas:

Population changes

Rural areas across the U.S. and across North Carolina are shrinking. Over the last decade, 51 counties in North Carolina lost population and many of these losses were in more rural counties in the Sandhills and Northeast regions of the state.

Migration patterns also vary significantly between the two locales. Nationally, urban areas have been rapidly gaining population by way of immigration, and suburban areas mainly through domestic migration. Rural areas, however, have a larger number of people exiting than they do moving in.

Age of population

Pew notes that “older adults are a higher share of the population in rural areas than in urban and suburban counties.”

Access to jobs and healthcare

An analysis from the Rural Health Research Project at UNC-Chapel Hill found that at least 181 rural hospitals have closed or stopped in-patient services nationwide since 2005. We also see a gap in job availability and wages: Analysis from the Agricultural Policy Review at Iowa State University found that rural areas had lower monthly labor force participation rates from January 2019 through May 2020. They attribute this to a variety of factors, including “differing employment opportunities, age structure [and] gender norms.”

The Economic Research Service at the U.S. Department of Agriculture notes, “From its post-recession low, in 2010, to 2017, rural wage and salary employment has grown at an average annual rate of 0.5%, compared to 1.8% in urban areas.”

Access to broadband

The Pew Research Center found that a quarter of people living in rural areas have said access to high-speed internet is a major problem. (An additional 34% of people living in rural areas say high-speed access is a minor problem — both categories are much greater than urban and suburban counterparts.)

Broadband internet access and availability is more variable in less densely populated regions, which has become increasingly apparent throughout the pandemic as adults and children have pivoted to online work and instruction. North Carolina tracks broadband availability and adoption across the state.

Getting urban versus rural from census for the first time since 2010

The Census Bureau reclassifies urban versus rural after every decennial census. The reclassification data will be released in 2022, at a date to be announced.

The 2010 census identified 3,573 urban areas nationwide representing roughly 81% of the U.S. population at the time. In contrast, 97% of the country’s land area is deemed rural while holding less than 20% of the country’s population.

North Carolina’s population was 66% urban in 2010 and this proportion will likely increase. The 2020 census shows some of the state’s more rural counties have seen declines in population relative to 2010 counts — Tyrell (-26%), Hyde (-21%), Anson (-18%) — to name a few, while more urban areas continue to rise — Wake (+25%), Durham (+21%), Mecklenburg (+21%).

Though many rural areas have lost population, other rural counties, particularly those located near larger urban areas, have increased in population. Areas within counties such as Pender, where an increase of 15% was observed over the last 10 years, are becoming quickly developed as workers in neighboring cities like Wilmington seek housing. These changes will also increase the state’s urban population, as places that were previously classified as rural see their classification change to urban.

Across the nation urban areas have been rapidly gaining population by way of immigration. Rural areas across the U.S. and across North Carolina are shrinking. Over the last decade 51 counties in North Carolina lost population. Nationally, residents 65 and older only make up 13% of cities and 15% of suburbs. Nationally, residents 65 and older only make up 18% of the rural population. Wage and salary employment has grown at an average annual rate of 1.8% in urban areas. Rural wage and salary employment has grown at an average annual rate of 0.5%. Rural areas also had lower monthly labor force participation rates from January 2019 through May 2020. Urban residents live an average of 5 miles away from the nearest hospital, which is half the distance of rural residents. At least 181 rural hospitals have closed or stopped in-patient services nationwide since 2005. Only 13% of Americans who live in urban areas view access to high-speed internet service as a major problem in their area. Access to high-speed internet is a major problem for 25% of people living in rural areas and a minor problem for an additional 34% of people in rural areas.

(Infographic by Leighann Vinesett/The Well)

Read more stories about Carolina Demography.